I love the book, “Breaking the Good Mom Myth” by Alyson Schafer. The book is not particularly religious in nature, but the insights are just common-sense. I can’t help but relate to a LOT of this stuff. The last myth to bust is: “Good Mothers Make Life Fun and Entertaining”. Watch it, Mom. Agreeing like that could get you whiplash. My mom has been telling me for ages that I don’t have to pay so much attention to the kids. That I don’t have to entertain them. She can see what I cannot: that we have done a 180 from when she raised us. I think that my Mom was raised in the Children should be seen and not heard era. And she balanced, from what I remember quite well, being a woman first, and a mom too. Now, we are definitely child-centered.
Alyson writes:
We’ve become mom-u-tainment for our children. We’ve taken it upon ourselves to become our children’s full time playmate and constant companion. The mom-u-tainment mom is a fun-loving gal-pal who takes her place down on the floor amid the Lego, playing gleefully all day long with her children. She’s a regular MacGyver too - turning egg cartons into caterpillars, coffee filters into butterflies.
What hits me about this - other than my hand slapping my knee - is that this is how I measure my mothering. As well as the way my Mom did: a clean house, and neat orderly schedule. So, now I have to be MacGyver Gal-Pal, and Martha all rolled into one. Hmmm. Was that my self esteem I heard hitting bottom?
She writes again:
I know not everyone is a mom-u-tainment mom. Some have made peace with the fact… but they can certainly make up for any fun that might be lacking by opening up their wallets! You can take them to the make-your-own-teddy-bear store, and then pick up the tab for lunch at the Rainforest Cafe (where the moving, life-sized elephants will either thrill your tot or make him shriek in pure terror). There’s the inside play-palace, clay painting, or just grab a movie and go an hour early so you can play in the “midway” first. Ah, yes, every day is a spectacular fun-day in childhood now.
I admit - I’ve done this myself. Especially in the worst days of depression. I pop up the indoor tent, throw some kid-sized chairs in there, and maybe even the portable dvd player and they’re entertained for hours. And it does work - they are quite distracted, and don’t seem to notice that Mommy’s in her own world. Now, I’m not saying that this is wrong - sometimes we do what we need to do to survive. I call this “survival mode”. You know the one? Where hot dogs are lunch, and supper is McDonalds that Daddy brought home. And you’re doing really well if you get the baby’s diaper changed.
Also, so true is the reaction that the kids get if they are unappreciative! Ohhhh boy! Watch the hammer come down on that one! How dare they? After all I do for them? Have they no idea that other kids would die to have a home like they do? etc, etc, etc. Isn’t it interesting though, that they are simply reflecting our attitude? Isn’t it true that if they are “done” with one toy, we bring out another? Isn’t it true that if something breaks we will replace it? I was patting myself on the back for not falling into this trap. Until I realized that if it is important (like their play dough - why would I let all those playdough toys go to waste without buying more dough?) then I cave. But it is MY decision, darn it! If I wanted to, they would SOOOO have to do without! In my head, I am soooo in control here.
There are hidden costs to all this mom-u-tainment, whether in person or purchase, Alyson points out that boredom creates self-entertainment. And self-directed play creates social skills, experimenting, and imagination. Take this example:
I observed a great example of the power of non-adult-directed, free, unstructured play one day at a nursery school. A group of girls had made their way to the kitchen area and were playing house. Another group of boys were playing with the block set. What happened next was the workings of two social groups trying to figure out how to play together. One boy grabbed some plastic food from the girls, and ran it back to the boys’ block area. He put the food in the little corral they had built with blocks. The girls ran and snatched it back. After a few more rounds of robbing one another, which they did chuckling - having fun being sneaky and trying to outwit each other - they combined their games. All the food went to the boys who used the blocks to set up a food market, and the girls came to shop with their imaginary grocery carts.
Can you imagine what would have happened if one of us “on top of things” moms was watching? Whewwwwy - what a great opportunity for a lecture on….
Alyson got an email that she talks about in this chapter: Alyson: My child is three-and-a half years old and I can’t get anything done becasue she always has to be with me, or demands that I play with her. I feel guilty if I don’t, but I am tired of this ball-and-chain on my leg. When is it okay for me to let her play alone?
I wonder what some of you think about this one?